Skip to content
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Welcome to Blessed is She, where we love Jesus & you.

Free U.S. Standard Shipping On Orders $75+

Missio Supply Co. FAQ Shipping Contact
Search
  • Content
  • Shop
  • Community
  • Experiences
  • About
Blessed Is She
Account Search Cart
  • Content Toggle menu
    • Devotions
      Devotions
    • Blog
      Blog
    • BIS Member Community
      BIS Member Community
    • Podcast
      Podcast
    • Free Resources
      Free Resources
  • Shop Toggle menu
    • By Category Toggle menu
      • Accessories
      • Apparel
      • Books & Studies
      • Cards & Booklets
      • Drinkware
      • Home & Wall Decor
      • Candles
      • Jewelry
      • Journals
      • Rosaries
    • Featured Toggle menu
      • New
      • Best Sellers
      • 📒 Liturgical Planners
      • 💜 Advent 2025
      • 🎉 Up to 50% Off
      • Stocking Stuffers
      • For Men
      • For Kids
      • Gifts
      • Sale
      • Start a Return
    • ADVENT 2025
      ADVENT 2025
    • 2026 PLANNERS
      2026 PLANNERS
    • SHOP ALL
      SHOP ALL
  • Community Toggle menu
    • Blessed Brunches
    • Regional Groups
    • Small Group Studies
    • Blessed is She Membership Community
    • College Students
    • Retreat
  • Experiences
  • About Toggle menu
    • What's New
    • About Blessed is She
    • Staff + Writers
    • Support Blessed is She
Up to 50% off in the Shop ✨➡️
Welcome, we're so glad you're here 💜

You Can't Have It Both Ways

You Can't Have It Both Ways - Blessed Is She

For years before my deep conversion, I led a “double-soul-life.”

I am a cradle Catholic, but I truly encountered Jesus as a Person for the first time when I was in high school. Once I met His gaze, I couldn’t shake Him entirely. But I tried.

On the outside, I upheld moral standards. On the inside—in my personal, private life—I faltered. I defended the Church’s teachings, but turned a blind eye to the Commandments that were a little too inconvenient for a high school girl with a boyfriend. I refused to miss Mass, but avoided God in prayer. I led campaigns for the defense of life and clean water in third world countries, but would participate in ruthless gossip about a classmate.

I sought earthly pleasures and happiness while trying to be just good enough to warrant eternal happiness. I was the generation that Jesus speaks of in today’s Gospel. I wanted it all: both the ways of God and the ways of the world. I wanted to be a good Catholic while remaining attached to my sins. I desired to walk in the way of sinners while also delighting in the law of the Lord (Responsorial Psalm).

This double-soul-life never satisfied me. Eventually, my charade crumbled. I was left only with the reality of who I really was. And Him. He was always there.

And who I really was wanted all of who He really is. So I allowed Him to “teach you what is for your good, and lead you on the way you should go” (Isaiah 48:17). For the first time, I experienced lasting happiness, true peace, unmatched clarity, and authentic affirmation.

Of course, this is a lifelong journey. Daily, I have to choose Jesus over myself. Daily, I have to choose the way of holiness over the way of the world. Most days, I fail or fall short. But there’s not a day that passes without my deep understanding that I can’t have it both ways, and that my Lord’s way is the only one worth having.

Daily, I have to choose Jesus over myself.Click to tweet Twitter

To better understand and identify sin in your life, read the Catechism of the Catholic Church's section on it here.

Olivia Spears lives in Kentucky where the sweet tea and bourbon flow like milk and honey. She is the Blog Manager for Blessed is She and works from home as an editor and social media manager. She likes to binge novels and Netflix while raising her children and laughing with her husband. You can find out more about her here.

Blessed is She - Blessed Is She
About Blessed is She
View other posts from the author

Walk With Us this Advent
Get Your Prayerful Planner
Share
  • Facebook Share on Facebook
  • Twitter Share on Twitter
  • Pinterest Pin it
December 14, 2018 — Blessed Is She
Tags: Author_BlessedIsShe Devotions
Left Older Post Back to Devotions Newer Post Right

Left Grab Some Goodies Right

View all
Catholic Wall and Desk Calendar 2025 with liturgical dates
49% off
Left Right Quick buy
Catholic Wall and Desk Calendar 2026
$35.00 $69.00 Sale
Catholic Gold Charm Necklace  Blessed is She
Left Right Quick buy
Catholic Gold Charm Necklace Blessed is She
$86.00
Catholic Gold Charm Bracelet | Blessed is She
Left Right Quick buy
Catholic Gold Charm Bracelet | Blessed is She
$72.00
Catholic Men’s Prayer Journal — Always With Me | Blessed is She
Left Right Quick buy
Catholic Men’s Prayer Journal — Always With Me | Blessed is She
$35.00
Gospel Study on Luke — Preach in His Name | Blessed is She
Left Right Quick buy
Gospel Study on Luke — Preach in His Name | Blessed is She
$52.00
We Hope for What We Do Not See Crewneck Sweatshirt | Blessed is She
Left Right Quick buy
We Hope for What We Do Not See Crewneck Sweatshirt | Blessed is She
From $60.00
Grace Before Meals Catholic Prayer Poster – Elegant 24x36 Wall Art
Left Right Quick buy
Grace Before Meals Catholic Prayer Poster – Elegant 24x36 Wall Art
$60.00
marian statue catholic
33% off
Left Right Quick buy
Mary Statue – 12” Resin Virgin Mary Catholic Home Decor
$69.00 $103.00 Sale
Gold Cross Bracelet for Women | Blessed is She
Left Right Quick buy
Gold Cross Bracelet for Women | Blessed is She
$43.00
Faith-Based Reusable Mirror Clings – Inspirational Christian Mirror Stickers
Left Right Quick buy
Faith-Based Reusable Mirror Clings – Inspirational Christian Mirror Stickers
$9.00
scripture cards for women
20% off
Left Right Quick buy
Words of Life // Bible Verse Cards
$48.00 $60.00 Sale
Psalm 27 Throw Blanket
30% off
Left Right Quick buy
Psalm 27 Throw Blanket
$72.00 $103.00 Sale
amdg banner for home
Left Right Quick buy
For the Greater Glory of God Banner Tapestry (35x26)
$60.00
catholic digital planner for the academic year
Left Right Quick buy
Catholic Digital Planner for Liturgical Living
$43.00
2026 Calendar Year Catholic Liturgical Planner // Mini Layout
17% off
Left Right Quick buy
2026 Calendar Year Catholic Liturgical Planner // Mini Layout
$77.00 $93.00 Sale
2026 Calendar Year Catholic Liturgical Planner // Big Layout
23% off
Left Right Quick buy
2026 Calendar Year Catholic Liturgical Planner // Big Layout
$77.00 $100.00 Sale
Blessed is She Advent Bundle for Women – In Time Devotional, Rosary Bracelet & Desk Crucifix
20% off
Left Right Quick buy
Blessed is She Advent Bundle for Women – In Time Devotional, Rosary Bracelet & Desk Crucifix
$88.00 $110.00 Sale
Advent Women + Kids Bundle
20% off
Left Right Quick buy
Advent Women + Kids Bundle
$61.00 $76.00 Sale
Advent Women + Men's Bundle
20% off
Left Right Quick buy
Advent Women + Men's Bundle
$66.00 $82.00 Sale
Advent Family Bundle
21% off
Left Right Quick buy
Advent Family Bundle
$93.00 $117.00 Sale
Welcome to Blessed Is She

Blessed is She is a sisterhood of women who want to grow in their relationship with Jesus Christ through their Catholic faith.

Blessed Is She
Quick links
  • Support BIS
  • Subscribe to the Devos
  • About Us
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Affiliates Program
  • Wholesale Login
Social
  • YouTube
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • Amazon
American Express Diners Club Discover JCB Maestro Mastercard PayPal Union Pay Venmo Visa
  • Privacy Policy
  • Shipping & Returns
  • Terms of Service
© 2025 Blessed Is She. Powered by Shopify
To Top